BACKGROUND:: Volatile anesthetic prices differ substantially. But differences in drug-acquisition cost would be inconsequential if hospitalization was prolonged by more soluble anesthetics. The authors tested the hypothesis that the duration of hospitalization is prolonged with isoflurane anesthesia. METHODS:: Initially, the authors queried their electronic records and used propensity matching to generate homogeneous sets of adults having inpatient noncardiac surgery who were given desflurane, sevoflurane, and isoflurane. The authors then conducted a prospective alternating intervention trial in which adults (mostly having colorectal surgery) were assigned to isoflurane or sevoflurane, based on protocol. RESULTS:: In the retrospective analysis, the authors identified 3,488 triplets matched on isoflurane, desflurane, or sevoflurane from among 43,352 adults. The adjusted geometric mean (95% CI) hospital length-of-stay for the isoflurane cases was 2.76 days (2.69-2.83); this was longer than that observed for both desflurane (2.56 [2.50-2.63]; P < 0.001) and sevoflurane (2.49 [2.43-2.56]; P < 0.0001). In the prospective trial (N = 1,584 operations), no difference was found; the adjusted ratio of means (95% CI) of hospital length-of-stay in patients receiving isoflurane versus sevoflurane was 0.98 (0.88-1.10), P = 0.77, with adjusted geometric means (95% CI) estimated at 4.1 (3.8-4.4) and 4.2 days (3.8-.5), respectively. CONCLUSIONS:: Results of the propensity-matched retrospective analysis suggested that avoiding isoflurane significantly reduced the duration of hospitalization. In contrast, length-of-stay was comparable in our prospective trial. Volatile anesthetic choice should not be based on concerns about the duration of hospitalization. These studies illustrate the importance of following even the best retrospective analysis with a prospective trial.

BACKGROUND: Children with severe bronchospasm requiring mechanical ventilation may become refractory to conventional therapy. In these critically ill patients, isoflurane is an inhaled anesthetic agent available in some centers to treat bronchospasm. We hypothesized that isoflurane is safe and would lead to improved gas exchange in children with life-threatening bronchospasm refractory to conventional therapy. METHODS: A retrospective review was conducted and included mechanically ventilated children treated with isoflurane in a quaternary pediatric ICU for life-threatening bronchospasm, from 1993 to 2007. Demographic, blood gas, ventilator, and outcome data were collected. RESULTS: Thirty-one patients, with a mean age of 9.5 years (range 0.4-23 years) were treated with isoflurane, from 1993 to 2007. Mean time to initiation of isoflurane after intubation was 13 hours (0-120 h), and the mean maximum isoflurane dose was 1.1% (0.3-2.5%). Mean duration of isoflurane administration was 54.5 hours (range 1-181 h), with a total mean duration of mechanical ventilation of 252 hours (range 16-1,444 h). Isoflurane led to significant improvement in pH and P(CO(2)) within 4 hours of initiation (P ≤ .001). Complications during isoflurane administration included hypotension requiring vasoactive infusions in 24 (77%), arrhythmia in 3 (10%), neurologic side effects in 3 (10%), and pneumothorax in 1 (3%) patient. CONCLUSIONS: Isoflurane led to improvement in pH and P(CO(2)) within 4 hours in this series of mechanically ventilated patients with life-threatening bronchospasm. The majority of patients in this series developed hypotension, but there was a low incidence of other side effects related to isoflurane administration. Isoflurane appears to be an effective therapy in patients with life-threatening bronchospasm refractory to conventional therapy. However, further investigation is warranted, given the uncertain overall impact of isoflurane in this context.