Improving serious illness communication: a qualitative study of clinical culture
Paladino, Joanna ; Sanders, Justin J ; Fromme, Erik K ; Block, Susan ; Jacobsen, Juliet C ; Jackson, Vicki A ; Ritchie, Christine S ; Mitchell, Suzanne
Student Authors
Faculty Advisor
Academic Program
UMass Chan Affiliations
Document Type
Publication Date
Subject Area
Files
Embargo Expiration Date
Link to Full Text
Abstract
Objective: Communication about patients' values, goals, and prognosis in serious illness (serious illness communication) is a cornerstone of person-centered care yet difficult to implement in practice. As part of Serious Illness Care Program implementation in five health systems, we studied the clinical culture-related factors that supported or impeded improvement in serious illness conversations.
Methods: Qualitative analysis of semi-structured interviews of clinical leaders, implementation teams, and frontline champions.
Results: We completed 30 interviews across palliative care, oncology, primary care, and hospital medicine. Participants identified four culture-related domains that influenced serious illness communication improvement: (1) clinical paradigms; (2) interprofessional empowerment; (3) perceived conversation impact; (4) practice norms. Changes in clinicians' beliefs, attitudes, and behaviors in these domains supported values and goals conversations, including: shifting paradigms about serious illness communication from 'end-of-life planning' to 'knowing and honoring what matters most to patients;' improvements in psychological safety that empowered advanced practice clinicians, nurses and social workers to take expanded roles; experiencing benefits of earlier values and goals conversations; shifting from avoidant norms to integration norms in which earlier serious illness discussions became part of routine processes. Culture-related inhibitors included: beliefs that conversations are about dying or withdrawing care; attitudes that serious illness communication is the physician's job; discomfort managing emotions; lack of reliable processes.
Conclusions: Aspects of clinical culture, such as paradigms about serious illness communication and inter-professional empowerment, are linked to successful adoption of serious illness communication. Further research is warranted to identify effective strategies to enhance clinical culture and drive clinician practice change.
Source
Paladino J, Sanders JJ, Fromme EK, Block S, Jacobsen JC, Jackson VA, Ritchie CS, Mitchell S. Improving serious illness communication: a qualitative study of clinical culture. BMC Palliat Care. 2023 Jul 22;22(1):104. doi: 10.1186/s12904-023-01229-x. PMID: 37481530; PMCID: PMC10362669.